The Bill of Rights Sentinel, LATEST, March 2016. Get your e-copy  HERE 

Be sure you have read our groundbreaking "Why Jews Hate Guns"


"Face It, The Second Amendment
No Longer Serves Its Purpose"
alerts2016 / alert20160531.htm

Share/Bookmark
smalline

"Face It, The Second Amendment
No Longer Serves Its Purpose"

By Dan Zimmerman on May 30th, 2016

Without summarizing years worth of blogs and comments, maybe we can all agree that the Second Amendment, as written, no longer serves its purpose. Almost all the disagreement over the meaning of 2A is bound up in interpretation. So long as anyone can form an opinion, and so long as courts will act as a super-legislature (or defender of the public, depending), and as long as government officials believe they have an obligaiton to "fill-in-the-blanks" regarding common sense gun ownership, the fights over the current Amendment will continue . . .

Is it time to accept the reality that in the era in which we now live, the archaic form of expression codified in the Second Amendment is at the root of the issue? And that the Amendment needs to be re-written? Cries of "absolute" are not establishing truth, nor are those claims doing much of anything to move the political needle one way or the other.

The problem with the current wording of the Second Amendment is that we live in a culture of binary conditions, while the Amendment lives in a time of great change in the thinking of how a government should be established and maintained.

My proposal is to re-write the Second Amendment in such a way that it can't be contorted by interpretation. For example: .....

A re-write of the 2A could potentially be fraught with problems, but as many know with the current amendment, it has been open to broad interpretation - that being as negative as possible by those who seek disarmament. To the rest of us "shall not be infringed" is about as positive a statement as is possible. Follow our link to read Dan's example, which would appear to give greater protection though you may disagree - however, most nay sayer antis would probably trash it due to it not being 'reasonable' enough!

© 2016 JPFO All rights reserved.
jpfo@jpfo.org
1-800-869-1884

Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership
12500 NE 10th Pl.
Bellevue, WA 98005 USA

"America’s most aggressive defender of civil rights"
We make the NRA look like moderates

Join JPFO

Back to Top

Alert Copy Alerts Archive 

Recent JPFO Alert, 1 of 3 … May 30th 2016 – (hover cursor to pause)

NJ Denies Concealed Carry Permit to Lt Col with Top Secret Clearance: It is incredible that a Lt Col with such qualifications should be denied, and it takes "may issue" to the point of "sorry no cigar", whoever you are.

Recent JPFO Alert, 2 of 3 … May 27th 2016 – (hover cursor to pause)

The Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act: Facts and Policy: The PLCAA may be little understood, but here Kopel goes into considerable depth to explain - not many know the full details (read the entire piece).

Recent JPFO Alert, 3 of 3 … May 25th 2016 – (hover cursor to pause)

Hawaii Wants To Tie State Gun Registry To FBI Database:This is about as "Big Brother" as it gets, and if the truth be known it is not only blatantly anti-gun but, a classic precursor to confiscation if implemented.

The JPFO Alerts Index Page … Alerts page 2016 – (hover cursor to pause)

JPFO alerts? Our alerts contain valuable and educational material …… check back and see the many subjects we cover. From that page you can sign up for free email alerts - (top of page).

Discover JPFO films.

Buster

Back to Top


JOIN JPFO TODAY

DONATE TO JPFO

JPFO ALERTS AND SIGN UP

2016


Rabbi Dovid Bendory
JPFO's Rabbinic Director

A vital message from Rabbi Bendory

Discover the " 10 Commandments of Self Defense" (2 CD set).